I was recently corresponding with Andre Mossner who owns Retro Design 3D in Germany. They manufacture, among other things, 4 cam heads. We were corresponding about the difficulty to cast the heads and problems with porosity etc. Andre provided some information on the in period Porsche factory reject rate for 4 cam heads. A partial quote of Andre’s email is shown below.
“Casting the heads is not to be underestimated, it is extremely difficult. When I started the project, I was with the original fabricators of the heads near Stuttgart. They even still had the original drawings. During the conversation I was told that they had to scrap over half of the heads after machining because of porosity and leaks”.
Given the hi reject rate for heads you can see why a carrera cost nearly double what a pushrod car cost.
Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
- Bill Sargent
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: Thu Apr 10, 2008 11:03 am
- Tag: Faux-Cam
- Location: Seattle, Washington
Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
Regards,
Bill Sargent
#151489 59A Cab - Faux Cam
#159176 64C Cab
#460603 67 912
904 clone in the works
Bill Sargent
#151489 59A Cab - Faux Cam
#159176 64C Cab
#460603 67 912
904 clone in the works
- Jacques Lefriant
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 4668
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2010 1:50 pm
- Location: Washoe county NV
Re: Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
i was told that back in the day the mold took 43 pieces to assemble. many raw castings did not make it to the machining step. Now a big portion of the molds are done by 3D printers which can make more intricate cores. https://nam12.safelinks.protection.outl ... reserved=0
j
j
- John Brooks
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 2174
- Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 11:50 am
- Location: Whidbey Island WA.
- Contact:
Re: Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
Anyone know Elon Musk? His casting machine could probably do them a few dozen at a time, and with no porosity. The tooling would be expensive but it would be right.
John Brooks
62 Roadster
66 912
84 Cab
getting pushed around in porsches since 1965
62 Roadster
66 912
84 Cab
getting pushed around in porsches since 1965
- Harlan Halsey
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 2377
- Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2012 2:05 pm
- Location: No Cal SF Peninsula
Re: Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
The Carrera cylinder heads are a straightforward design, just what Furman thought he wanted I guess, but never optimized because they could be made at the time in post war Germany. They are difficult to make because they incorporate copper oil passage tubing and because of the high aspect ratio and close spacing of the fins. Furthermore, the gas passages are way too big. Essentially, they made a 9,000 RPM head and put it on a 6,000 RPM bottom end. Nevertheless, the Carrera is one of the most successful race engines of its time.
If there were a market to justify the cost, a modern optimization aimed at the original bottom end, would eliminate the copper tubing, simplify the manufacture, take another look at the finning, and optimize the gas flow for power at lower RPM. Apparently, this is what the Garretson/Kuzu three-piece redesign can do. They have not optimized the gas flow yet. If they are successful, we will have brand new cylinder heads which look just like the originals but are cheaper to make and make more useful power.
A more extreme optimization would look at the combustion chamber and probably conclude that a more 911 like chamber would produce more power but require different valve angles. But to what purpose?
If there were a market to justify the cost, a modern optimization aimed at the original bottom end, would eliminate the copper tubing, simplify the manufacture, take another look at the finning, and optimize the gas flow for power at lower RPM. Apparently, this is what the Garretson/Kuzu three-piece redesign can do. They have not optimized the gas flow yet. If they are successful, we will have brand new cylinder heads which look just like the originals but are cheaper to make and make more useful power.
A more extreme optimization would look at the combustion chamber and probably conclude that a more 911 like chamber would produce more power but require different valve angles. But to what purpose?
- Jacques Lefriant
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 4668
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2010 1:50 pm
- Location: Washoe county NV
Re: Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
Hi Harlan
the current available heads from Capricorn and Andre Moessner using modern casting methods are pricy but they meet our needs. i am of the opinion that changing the combustion chamber to 911 specifications is the only way to go since there has been 35 years of development.
j
the current available heads from Capricorn and Andre Moessner using modern casting methods are pricy but they meet our needs. i am of the opinion that changing the combustion chamber to 911 specifications is the only way to go since there has been 35 years of development.
j
- Martin Benade
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 12392
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:52 am
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Re: Factory Reject Rate for Casting 4 Cam Heads
If the stock head design (ports) is suited to very high RPM what limits the bottom end from keeping up?
Cleveland Ohio
62 Cabriolet
56 VW
02 IS 300
04 Sienna
62 Cabriolet
56 VW
02 IS 300
04 Sienna
- Jacques Lefriant
- 356 Fan
- Posts: 4668
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2010 1:50 pm
- Location: Washoe county NV