Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

For off-topic posts only (i.e. non 356 related content). No politics, religion or obscenity. Play nice!
Message
Author
User avatar
James Rogers
356 Fan
Posts: 17
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:36 am

Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#1 Post by James Rogers »

I'd like to hear from or get some thoughts here from members here that are old enough to have moved from the 356's to the early 911's from let say, 1965-1968S?
Attachments
265161_10150310609250185_7491684_n.jpg
265161_10150310609250185_7491684_n.jpg (13.85 KiB) Viewed 3198 times
 

User avatar
C J Murray
356 Fan
Posts: 9158
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2009 7:24 pm
Location: 30MI WEST OF PHILA
Contact:

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#2 Post by C J Murray »

Two completely different cars, owning a 911S will tell you little about owning a 356.
'57 Speedster
'59 Sunroof
'60 Devin D Porsche Race Car
'63 Cabriolet "Norm"
'67 911 S Original Owner
'03 Ferrari 575M
'09 Smart Passion

User avatar
Adam Wright
Classifieds Monitor
Posts: 10304
Joined: Wed Mar 12, 2008 1:00 am
Tag: KTF

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#3 Post by Adam Wright »

I know several guys who have restored many a 356 and decided to restore an early 911, and were very overwhelmed by the complexity of a 911, compared to the 356.
www.unobtanium-inc.com
Check out my Barn Find column in the Registry magazine, always looking for good stories.

User avatar
Joris Koning
356 Fan
Posts: 2505
Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 12:38 pm
Location: Netherlands

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#4 Post by Joris Koning »

Adam Wright wrote:I know several guys who have restored many a 356 and decided to restore an early 911, and were very overwhelmed by the complexity of a 911, compared to the 356.

Working on a '65 as a summer driver for the misses right now. A lot more shit going on in these compared to a 356. Enjoying the experience a lot. Not sure if it is more complex, just more areas/parts to address.
'56 Coupe
'57 Coupe
'59 Cab 
'60 Coupe

User avatar
Adam Wright
Classifieds Monitor
Posts: 10304
Joined: Wed Mar 12, 2008 1:00 am
Tag: KTF

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#5 Post by Adam Wright »

Joris Koning wrote:
Adam Wright wrote:I know several guys who have restored many a 356 and decided to restore an early 911, and were very overwhelmed by the complexity of a 911, compared to the 356.

Working on a '65 as a summer driver for the misses right now. A lot more shit going on in these compared to a 356. Enjoying the experience a lot. Not sure if it is more complex, just more areas/parts to address.
It gets worse the newer they get. Trying to find someone who can re-build and tune MFI is tough, compared to someone who can do carbs.
www.unobtanium-inc.com
Check out my Barn Find column in the Registry magazine, always looking for good stories.

User avatar
Joris Koning
356 Fan
Posts: 2505
Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 12:38 pm
Location: Netherlands

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#6 Post by Joris Koning »

Adam Wright wrote:
Joris Koning wrote:
Adam Wright wrote:I know several guys who have restored many a 356 and decided to restore an early 911, and were very overwhelmed by the complexity of a 911, compared to the 356.

Working on a '65 as a summer driver for the misses right now. A lot more shit going on in these compared to a 356. Enjoying the experience a lot. Not sure if it is more complex, just more areas/parts to address.
It gets worse the newer they get. Trying to find someone who can re-build and tune MFI is tough, compared to someone who can do carbs.
Indeed. I also have a more modern 911, the misses drives it. Just replaced all suspension arms and a host of other parts. Will not touch any of the electronics nor some of the hard to get to engine stuff. To much shit going on with those cars. Glad to pay somebody else to do those jobs. You gotta love the simple design of the 356, everything is easy to get to, simple, made of quality materials etc. the perfect cars for amateurs like me to work on
'56 Coupe
'57 Coupe
'59 Cab 
'60 Coupe

User avatar
Jim Alton
356 Fan
Posts: 1772
Joined: Sun Mar 30, 2008 12:11 pm
Location: Los Angeles County

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#7 Post by Jim Alton »

I must have done things backwards. I got this in 1997:
1965 Porsche 911
1965 Porsche 911
And this in 2004:
1958 Porsche 356A
1958 Porsche 356A
A few points:

Complexity (at least in my view as an Aerospace Systems Engineer) isn't hugely different although the 911's wiring diagram has twice as much stuff as the 356's. The '65 911 adds backup lights and the ability to turn on the parking lights on one side via the turn signal lever.

Engine Access is easier in the 911 as is engine R&R (although the 911 engine-transaxle is a lot heavier than the 356 engine).

Fuel Consumption is way, way less in the 356.

Noise The 356 is quieter and the radio's easier to hear. An interesting thing about the Cabriolet is that near 60 mph with the top down (if it's not too windy, i.e. turbulent) the 356 Cab's aerodynamics form a sort of cone of silence and it's really, really quiet.

Driveability
  1. All the controls are lighter in the 911 and its rack-and-pinion steering is incredible.
  2. The early 911's low-end torque is underwhelming (the 2.4 liter cars are supposed to be different) so you shift gears a lot; the 356 is happy in just about any gear.
  3. 140 hp DIN in the 911 doesn't sound like a lot but it's effortlessly fast. A 356A with "Speedster" gears... not so much.
There's nothing wrong with having one of each! Not that I could have one of either with today's prices...
 
Jim Alton
Los Angeles County, CA
1958 Porsche 356A Cabriolet
1965 Porsche 911 Coupé
1966 Volkswagen Type 2
2003 Porsche 986 Boxster

User avatar
C J Murray
356 Fan
Posts: 9158
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2009 7:24 pm
Location: 30MI WEST OF PHILA
Contact:

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#8 Post by C J Murray »

356 coupes are as noisy as the 911 coupes. Life in the tin can.
'57 Speedster
'59 Sunroof
'60 Devin D Porsche Race Car
'63 Cabriolet "Norm"
'67 911 S Original Owner
'03 Ferrari 575M
'09 Smart Passion

User avatar
Adam Wright
Classifieds Monitor
Posts: 10304
Joined: Wed Mar 12, 2008 1:00 am
Tag: KTF

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#9 Post by Adam Wright »

Personally I like different ends of the spectrum. I have a 60 Roadster, and a 95 993 as my drivers. Working on a bunch of projects that are years away from the road. I also have a C43 AMG Mercedes for raw speed, and a 65 Mustang for getting ice cream with the kids and doing local car shows.
Having Porsches that we only 10-15 years apart seems kind of redundant. I know a 911S is a far different car from a 356, but they are still both air cooled cars with early and sometimes crude systems. Variety is nice.
www.unobtanium-inc.com
Check out my Barn Find column in the Registry magazine, always looking for good stories.

User avatar
John Lindstrom
356 Fan
Posts: 336
Joined: Mon Oct 23, 2017 9:51 am
Location: Stanford, Ca. USA

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#10 Post by John Lindstrom »

Bring it by my place so I can show you how to drive it properly hahaha

User avatar
Jim Alton
356 Fan
Posts: 1772
Joined: Sun Mar 30, 2008 12:11 pm
Location: Los Angeles County

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#11 Post by Jim Alton »

Joris Koning wrote:. . .

Indeed. I also have a more modern 911, the misses drives it. Just replaced all suspension arms and a host of other parts. Will not touch any of the electronics nor some of the hard to get to engine stuff. To much shit going on with those cars. Glad to pay somebody else to do those jobs. You gotta love the simple design of the 356, everything is easy to get to, simple, made of quality materials etc. the perfect cars for amateurs like me to work on
Lord yes.

I had to change the water pump on my Boxster. It was roughly $ 250 for parts (one pump, one gasket and a couple jugs of genuine Porsche anti-freeze). I understand the whole job at an independent Porsche repair shop is over $ 1,000! That's a ton of labor charge.

It's kind of like rebuilding an engine in a bottle: the pump's hidden just below the opening in the firewall behind the seats and the little 6 mm bolts that hold it on a murder to get a wrench on.
Last edited by Jim Alton on Tue Nov 21, 2017 11:55 pm, edited 2 times in total.
 
Jim Alton
Los Angeles County, CA
1958 Porsche 356A Cabriolet
1965 Porsche 911 Coupé
1966 Volkswagen Type 2
2003 Porsche 986 Boxster

Edwin Ek
356 Fan
Posts: 1898
Joined: Sat Jun 21, 2008 11:16 am
Location: Santa Monica, CA

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#12 Post by Edwin Ek »

My '73 S is a hell of a lot quicker. The engine noises are more modern. The steering is more precise, but they both are unassisted which is dynamite. The link between the old and new is strong, but the progress is immense.
#6386

Greg Stout
356 Fan
Posts: 85
Joined: Wed Sep 30, 2015 1:37 pm
Location: Santa Cruz-Capitola, CA

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#13 Post by Greg Stout »

You can not compare a 911 and a 356/912, anymore then you can compare hang gliding and fighter jets.
I have owned quite a few 911's, and, honestly....intoxicating as they are, they are also a pain in the ass to do even basic maintenance (valve adj/carb adj, or God help you the MFI goes sideways....) I finally swore off of 911's 2 years ago, sold my last one and bought my T-5 coupe....and my brain went "AHHHhhhhhhhh"...peace at last.

You like the "900" body style (it IS mightly purdy) then, may I suggest a 912...
Member # 1809 , June 1978
'60 Cab-'60 Rdstr-Envimo S:90
'60 Rdstr-'64 C Cpe-'62 Cab
Envimo S:90-'63 Cpe-'62 Cpe
above…all Sold and long gone….
current Garage Pals…
IM Roadster D
1960 T-5 Coupe (52nd one built)
1968 912 Coupe

User avatar
James Rogers
356 Fan
Posts: 17
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:36 am

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#14 Post by James Rogers »

Since getting my 67 911SWT back on the road (for the 1st times since I bought it 2011) last summer and two two major repair to fix everything under the sun, I can say, it was worth every single penny. With just over 50K on the original factory built motor (yes, the Targa only has 50K total mileage) and now back to flawless performance and not one drop of oil leaking. The versatility of the SWT (all buttoned up, Targa top off or back window removed or even thing off) is it's strong point and you'd never really understand it unless you owned and operated one.
Attachments
1967 SWT 10-19_3.jpg
1967 SWT 10-19_3.jpg (380.82 KiB) Viewed 1226 times
 

User avatar
Jules Dielen
356 Fan
Posts: 3165
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 3:25 pm
Location: Arizona

Re: Early 911/S in Lieu of the 356

#15 Post by Jules Dielen »

just enjoy both Jim, they each have their strong points. It's like asking for the 'best' 356 - you will get 50 different answers. I like the 356 because of its simplicity and the sound. I like my SWT for the sound and simplicity :) they both keep up up with traffic just fine, even the Pre A will do 75mph all day long, and as long as I don't have to turn or use the brakes it puts a big grin on my face. A C or an SC isn't that far behind a swb 911 other than the sound. Handles well, shifts well, brakes well and plenty powerful.

Happy to see the SWT is back on the road after all these years!
Jules

Water pumps are for windshield washers only.

Post Reply